This analysis identifies that around 15% of students typically score all four Critical Voice elements both negatively and there are further concerns with the additional 25 to 30% that tend to feel comfortable with critical thinking but not conversations across differences as well as feeling they have voice inside but not outside class.

…two thirds of the students positively affirm that the school does support understand their identities while slightly less than 50% believe the school teaches them to learn how to think versus simply taking in facts and mastering skills. Which quality is more foundational and how are they interdependent?

…3rd and 4th graders have between a 20 and 25% higher probability of being in the group of negative/low scores, while students identifying as Prefer to be Alone show an additional 15% probability of negative/low scores.

…the “Social” demographic divides into three categories: Prefer to be Alone, Wishing for More Friends and Large Network of Friends. Results for K – 4 show that students identifying in each category have a distinct developmental experience.

Since the set of qualities measured are believed to reinforce one another to varying degrees, but always in a positive manner, weak correlations between qualities require consideration. The nature of the faculty “Deeper Contradictions” output varies significantly between schools. Using six examples, the narrative and data examine the implications of a large set of contradictions in a faculty survey.

Analysis quantifies the risks of reporting a negative Trauma scoring meaning the student was traumatized. The highest risk factors are linked to the identities Gender Other, Prefer to be Alone under Social, and Diagnosed Learning Disabilities. Each identity alone adds 10% or more risk.

Comparing faculty quality scores of their views of the student experience, the most optimistic positive difference on average is +1.0 for the quality Academic Validation. At the other extreme, faculty are most overly pessimistic about the Socioeconomic quality by an even larger factor of -1.5.

In each of the three grade-based phases (Lower, Middle and Upper School), students tend to begin with a more positive outlook which then declines as they move forward in that phase. Interestingly, when students transition to the next phase, their views of the school demonstrably improve and they restart the cycle.

In early surveys’ identity selections 7-12 students chose “Prefer not to answer” 3% of the the time. In 5 or so years this level nearly tripled to over 8%. The range across individual schools is 5% for the lowest schools to 10%. Some surveys encounter as much as 20% selection for Sexual Orientation and Political identities.

Play helps develop cultural competence, dealing with power and conflict, interacting with emotional dynamics as well as concepts around fairness.

Student feedback confirms the strongest linkages between a broad range of relationships (associations) with three aspirational qualities: Multicultural Orientation, Socio-emotional Development, and Voice in Class.